Knowledge Battery Testing What are the key pathways of the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction (HER)? Achieve Reliable Electrocatalyst Testing with Precision Sample Preparation
Author avatar

Tech Team · Kintek Solution

Updated 3 months ago

What are the key pathways of the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction (HER)? Achieve Reliable Electrocatalyst Testing with Precision Sample Preparation


The Hydrogen Evolution Reaction (HER) proceeds through two main pathways: both begin with electrochemical hydrogen adsorption through the Volmer step, then continue either through electrochemical hydrogen release via the Heyrovsky step or chemical recombination through the Tafel step. Precise sample preparation is essential because catalyst loading, film thickness, density, contact resistance, and structural uniformity directly affect measured overpotential and Tafel kinetics.

Key takeaway: HER mechanism is determined by how adsorbed hydrogen is formed and converted into H₂, while reliable mechanism and performance comparisons require electrodes made with tightly controlled preparation procedures.

The Two Principal HER Pathways

The shared Volmer step

The catalyst surface is represented by *, and adsorbed hydrogen by *H or *Had.

In acidic electrolyte, the Volmer step is:

* + H⁺ + e⁻ ⇌ *Had

A proton receives an electron and becomes hydrogen adsorbed on an available catalyst site.

The Volmer–Heyrovsky pathway

The Heyrovsky step is an electrochemical desorption process:

*Had + H⁺ + e⁻ ⇌ H₂ + *

Here, an adsorbed hydrogen atom reacts with a proton and an electron to produce molecular hydrogen and regenerate the active site.

This pathway is therefore a two-step electrochemical sequence: hydrogen adsorption followed by electrochemical H₂ formation.

The Volmer–Tafel pathway

The Tafel step is a chemical recombination process:

2 *Had ⇌ H₂ + 2*

Two adsorbed hydrogen atoms combine directly to form molecular hydrogen, without an additional electron-transfer step.

This pathway is also a two-step sequence, but its hydrogen-forming step is chemical rather than electrochemical.

How Alkaline HER Differs

Water dissociation becomes part of the Volmer step

In alkaline electrolyte, hydrogen is generally supplied by water rather than by abundant free protons:

* + H₂O + e⁻ ⇌ *Had + OH⁻

The catalyst must therefore facilitate water activation, hydrogen adsorption, and hydroxide formation.

The same two routes follow afterward

Once *Had is formed, the reaction can proceed through either:

  • Heyrovsky: electrochemical reaction of adsorbed hydrogen with water and electron transfer.
  • Tafel: chemical recombination of two adsorbed hydrogen atoms.

The distinction between the pathways remains the same, but alkaline HER adds the challenge of water dissociation and hydroxide management.

What Controls HER Activity

Hydrogen binding must be balanced

The Sabatier principle states that catalytic activity is highest when the catalyst binds reaction intermediates neither too weakly nor too strongly.

For HER, this balance is commonly described using the hydrogen adsorption free energy, ΔG°Hads.

Weak and strong hydrogen binding both limit performance

If hydrogen adsorption is too weak, the catalyst cannot effectively activate or retain the hydrogen intermediate.

If adsorption is too strong, *Had becomes difficult to convert into H₂ or remove from the surface, slowing subsequent reaction steps.

This relationship produces the well-known HER volcano trend, with high exchange current density near thermoneutral hydrogen adsorption.

Interfaces can tune the reaction environment

In alkaline HER, different sites can perform complementary roles. For example, NiO/Ni heterostructures can combine hydroxide-tolerant or water-activation behavior at oxide-associated sites with hydrogen adsorption at metallic Ni sites.

The broader principle is that catalyst composition and interfaces can tune hydrogen binding and reduce limitations associated with water dissociation or hydroxide site blocking.

Why Sample Preparation Determines Test Reliability

The electrode is part of the measurement

Electrochemical testing does not measure catalyst powder in isolation. It measures a complete electrode containing the catalyst, substrate, conductive network, binder or coating system, electrolyte-accessible surface, and electrical contact.

Variations in any of these features can change the apparent activity even when the catalyst chemistry is identical.

Catalyst loading must be controlled

The catalyst loading determines how much material contributes to the measured current and affects the interpretation of current density.

Inconsistent loading makes comparisons between samples unreliable and can distort reported values such as the overpotential at 10 mA cm⁻², commonly written as η@10.

Film thickness and density affect transport

A nonuniform or overly thick catalyst layer can introduce differences in electrolyte penetration, ion transport, electron transport, and gas release.

Precision pressing and coating help produce consistent layer thickness and density, making performance differences more likely to reflect catalyst properties rather than electrode construction.

Electrical contact must remain reproducible

Poor or variable contact between catalyst, support, and current collector introduces contact resistance.

That resistance can increase the apparent potential required to reach a target current and may make a catalyst appear less active than it is.

Structural variation can distort kinetics

Powder compaction, coating, and drying can alter cracking, porosity, aggregation, and the accessibility of active sites.

The goal is not to eliminate every structural feature—defects and interfaces may be catalytically important—but to ensure that structural differences are deliberate, characterized, and reproducible.

Connecting Preparation to Tafel Analysis

Tafel slopes are sensitive to electrode quality

Tafel analysis relates overpotential to the logarithm of current density and is used to assess apparent reaction kinetics.

However, the measured slope can be affected by uncompensated resistance, mass transport, bubble coverage, changing active area, and nonuniform catalyst films—not only by the intrinsic HER mechanism.

A slope does not prove a mechanism by itself

Tafel slopes can provide clues about the rate-limiting regime and possible Volmer, Heyrovsky, or Tafel involvement.

They should not be treated as definitive proof of a single elementary pathway without supporting evidence, because real electrodes may operate under mixed control and may change behavior across the measured potential range.

Low-overpotential data require particular care

Accurate linear polarization measurements at low overpotentials are important for determining exchange current density and comparing intrinsic kinetics.

At these small signals, contact resistance, background current, reference-electrode errors, and sample nonuniformity can become proportionally significant.

Understanding the Trade-offs

High loading is not automatically better

Increasing catalyst loading can increase geometric current, but it can also produce thicker films, poorer transport, more difficult bubble removal, and greater resistance.

A larger current therefore does not necessarily indicate better intrinsic catalytic activity.

Pressing can improve consistency but alter morphology

Pressing powders into dense pellets or layers can improve dimensional and electrical reproducibility.

Excessive compaction, however, may reduce porosity or block electrolyte access, so processing pressure must be standardized rather than maximized.

Smooth films are not always ideal

A highly uniform film improves comparison between samples, but roughness, porosity, and accessible defects may contribute to genuine catalytic activity.

The correct objective is controlled morphology, not indiscriminate smoothing or removal of all defects.

Benchmark values need experimental context

Metrics such as η@10 mA cm⁻² and the Tafel slope are useful only when accompanied by relevant test conditions.

Electrolyte composition, substrate, catalyst loading, electrode area, resistance compensation, scan conditions, and cell configuration can all influence the reported result.

How to Apply This to Your Project

The most reliable workflow connects mechanistic interpretation with disciplined electrode fabrication and measurement.

  • If your primary focus is identifying the HER pathway: Use the Volmer–Heyrovsky and Volmer–Tafel schemes as mechanistic frameworks, but interpret Tafel slopes alongside controlled electrochemical and structural evidence.
  • If your primary focus is comparing catalyst activity: Standardize catalyst loading, film thickness, density, substrate, electrolyte, electrode area, and resistance compensation before comparing η@10 or Tafel slopes.
  • If your primary focus is alkaline HER: Pay particular attention to water-dissociation behavior, hydroxide effects, and catalyst interfaces rather than evaluating hydrogen adsorption alone.
  • If your primary focus is reproducibility: Use controlled powder processing, precision pressing, and coating procedures to minimize variations in contact resistance, morphology, and catalyst-layer structure.

Reliable HER conclusions begin with electrodes whose preparation is as controlled as the chemistry they are intended to measure.

Summary Table:

Pathway Steps Description
Volmer-Heyrovsky Volmer: * + H⁺ + e⁻ ⇌ *Had; Heyrovsky: *Had + H⁺ + e⁻ ⇌ H₂ + * Electrochemical adsorption followed by electrochemical desorption; two electron-transfer steps.
Volmer-Tafel Volmer: * + H⁺ + e⁻ ⇌ *Had; Tafel: 2 Had ⇌ H₂ + 2 Electrochemical adsorption followed by chemical recombination; only one electron-transfer step.
Alkaline Variant Volmer includes water dissociation: * + H₂O + e⁻ ⇌ *Had + OH⁻; then Heyrovsky or Tafel Water activation and hydroxide management add complexity in alkaline media.

Ensure your HER experiments yield reliable, publishable data with KINTEK's precision pressing and coating equipment. Our solutions are designed for battery R&D and advanced materials research, providing consistent electrode fabrication for accurate electrocatalyst testing. Contact us today to discuss your lab's needs and discover how we can enhance your research—get in touch!


Leave Your Message