Nickel-based HER catalysts mainly lose activity because their surface converts from metallic Ni to a less active hydride-containing state during prolonged operation. Surface nickel hydride (Ni–H) can form through adsorbed hydrogen intermediates or through reaction with dissolved hydrogen in the electrolyte. The resulting surface requires a larger driving potential, increases the Tafel slope, and slows hydrogen desorption; surface oxidation and hydroxide adsorption can further impede the reaction.
Core takeaway: Activity decay should be evaluated as both an electrochemical and a materials change. Stable long-duration testing, combined with before-and-after measurements such as polarization analysis, XRD, and SEM, helps determine whether declining HER performance originates from Ni–H formation, surface chemical changes, or morphological evolution.
Why Nickel HER Activity Declines
Formation of surface nickel hydride
During HER, hydrogen-containing intermediates are continuously generated on the nickel surface. These species can participate in forming surface Ni–H.
Dissolved molecular hydrogen can also contribute to hydride formation. Under extended operation, the surface may therefore become increasingly different from the initial metallic nickel state.
Ni–H is less active than metallic nickel
Nickel hydride has a lower electronic density of states near the relevant d-band states than metallic Ni. This changes the surface interaction with hydrogen and makes the hydrogen desorption step less favorable.
As a result, Ni–H requires a higher driving potential to sustain the same HER rate. The kinetic consequence is commonly observed as an increase in the apparent Tafel slope and a loss of current at a given potential.
Surface oxidation and hydroxide adsorption
Nickel surfaces can also develop oxidized or hydroxide-containing species, particularly when the local surface environment favors oxidation or hydroxide adsorption. These species compete with hydrogen intermediates for active surface sites.
Adsorbed hydrogen may react with surface oxygen- or hydroxide-containing species to reform water. This additional pathway consumes hydrogen intermediates and can slow the net HER kinetics.
How Degradation Is Analyzed
Establish a reliable electrochemical baseline
A stable electrochemical test cell is essential because apparent decay can arise from changing resistance, electrolyte composition, temperature, bubble coverage, or electrode positioning rather than intrinsic catalyst degradation.
Before long-term testing, record the catalyst’s initial polarization behavior. The same measurements should be repeated after operation so that changes in overpotential, current density, and Tafel slope can be compared directly.
Track activity during extended operation
Long-duration galvanostatic or potentiostatic testing reveals whether the required potential increases at constant current or whether the current decreases at constant potential.
Useful indicators include:
- Increasing overpotential: more driving force is needed to maintain the reaction rate.
- Increasing Tafel slope: the apparent reaction kinetics have worsened.
- Declining current: the catalyst is producing less hydrogen under the same operating conditions.
- Changing cell resistance: part of the apparent loss may be electrical rather than catalytic.
Electrochemical measurements should therefore be normalized and interpreted alongside cell resistance and operating conditions.
Use XRD to identify phase changes
X-ray diffraction can compare the catalyst before and after extended HER operation. It is useful for identifying changes in crystalline phases, including evidence of altered nickel-containing phases or other structural transformations.
However, XRD is less sensitive to very thin or poorly crystalline surface layers. Because Ni–H formation may be primarily a surface phenomenon, a lack of a strong new diffraction peak does not by itself prove that hydride-related degradation did not occur.
Use SEM to examine morphology
Scanning electron microscopy reveals morphological evolution, such as changes in particle structure, cracking, agglomeration, or loss of surface features.
These observations help determine whether activity loss is associated with physical restructuring. SEM should not be treated as a standalone chemical identification method: it can show that morphology changed, but it generally cannot establish the presence of surface Ni–H by itself.
Correlate electrochemical and materials evidence
The strongest degradation diagnosis links the timing of activity loss with changes in the catalyst. For example, a rising overpotential accompanied by altered nickel phases or surface morphology provides stronger evidence than either observation alone.
The analysis should also distinguish intrinsic catalyst decay from operational artifacts. Gas-bubble accumulation, poor electrical contact, electrolyte contamination, and changes in exposed area can all produce an apparent decline in HER performance.
Understanding the Trade-offs
Hydride formation is difficult to observe directly
Surface Ni–H may be transient, thin, or poorly crystalline. Consequently, post-operation characterization can underestimate the chemical state that existed under working HER conditions.
This is why electrochemical trends and structural characterization should be interpreted together rather than relying on a single measurement.
Bulk characterization may miss surface degradation
XRD primarily reports crystalline material and may not detect a surface layer that controls catalytic activity. SEM provides morphology but limited chemical specificity.
The analytical methods are therefore complementary: electrochemistry measures functional loss, XRD examines phase evolution, and SEM examines morphological evolution.
Activity loss does not always mean catalyst loss
A catalyst can retain much of its physical structure while becoming less active because its surface electronic state or adsorbate coverage has changed. Conversely, visible restructuring may occur without being the dominant cause of the kinetic decline.
The key question is not simply whether the electrode looks different, but whether the active nickel surface has changed in a way that explains the electrochemical response.
How to Apply This to Your Project
Use a time-resolved testing and characterization plan rather than evaluating the catalyst only before and after operation.
- If your primary focus is identifying the chemical cause of decay: Compare initial and post-operation electrochemical kinetics with XRD evidence for nickel-phase changes, while recognizing that surface Ni–H may not be fully visible by XRD.
- If your primary focus is measuring operational stability: Run the catalyst in a stable, controlled cell and continuously track potential or current, resistance, and test conditions over the full HER duration.
- If your primary focus is diagnosing physical degradation: Use SEM to compare morphology before and after testing, then correlate cracking, agglomeration, or restructuring with changes in HER activity.
- If your primary focus is separating intrinsic decay from measurement artifacts: Include controls for bubble coverage, electrolyte condition, electrical contact, exposed area, and cell resistance before assigning the performance loss to catalyst degradation.
A defensible degradation analysis connects the electrochemical loss of activity to the formation of less-active surface states and independently observed changes in catalyst structure.
Summary Table:
| Cause of Decay | Description | Analysis Method |
|---|---|---|
| Surface Nickel Hydride (Ni–H) | Less active than metallic Ni, slows hydrogen desorption, increases Tafel slope | Tafel slope analysis, polarization curves |
| Surface Oxidation/Hydroxide Adsorption | Competes with H intermediates, blocks active sites | XPS, cyclic voltammetry |
| Morphological Changes | Cracking, agglomeration, restructuring | SEM, TEM |
| Operational Artifacts | Bubble coverage, resistance changes, electrolyte contamination | Control experiments, EIS |
Enhance your HER degradation studies with KINTEK's advanced electrochemical cells and characterization equipment. Our solutions support precise long-term testing and materials analysis for battery R&D and advanced materials. Contact our experts today to optimize your catalyst evaluation workflow – get in touch!