Knowledge Battery Testing What key electrochemical parameters and electrolyte considerations are critical for evaluating Ni/Co HER electrocatalysts?
Author avatar

Tech Team · Kintek Solution

Updated 3 months ago

What key electrochemical parameters and electrolyte considerations are critical for evaluating Ni/Co HER electrocatalysts?


The most important evaluation parameters are the overpotential at 10 mA cm⁻², Tafel slope, stability, and electrolyte compatibility. For nickel- and cobalt-based HER catalysts, η₁₀ indicates the extra voltage required to achieve a practical benchmark current, while the Tafel slope helps describe reaction kinetics. These values are meaningful only when electrolyte composition, electrode preparation, loading, reference electrode, iR correction, and measurement protocol are reported consistently.

A low η₁₀ does not by itself prove superior catalytic performance. Reliable evaluation requires comparing η₁₀ and Tafel slope under identical conditions, testing in both acidic and alkaline electrolytes, and confirming activity, stability, and current efficiency with carefully prepared electrodes.

Start with the Core HER Performance Metrics

Overpotential at 10 mA cm⁻²

The overpotential at 10 mA cm⁻², commonly written as η₁₀, is the primary activity metric for many laboratory HER studies. It is the additional potential beyond the thermodynamic hydrogen-evolution potential required to reach that current density.

Lower η₁₀ generally indicates that less electrical energy is required to produce hydrogen at the selected benchmark current. Report whether the value is based on geometric current density and whether the potential has been corrected for solution resistance.

The reference values in the supplied literature include overpotentials below approximately 70 mV for highly active structures such as porous NiSe₂ foams and phosphorus-doped CoS₂ nanosheets under appropriate conditions.

Tafel Slope

The Tafel slope, expressed in mV dec⁻¹, is derived from the relationship between overpotential and the logarithm of current density. It is used to assess apparent HER kinetics and to help identify changes in the rate-controlling behavior.

A smaller slope generally means that the current increases more rapidly with applied overpotential. However, the slope is sensitive to the selected fitting range, uncompensated resistance, mass transport, catalyst loading, and surface-state changes.

Values below approximately 40 mV dec⁻¹ are reported for some highly active nickel- and cobalt-based materials, while porous NiSe₂ foams have also been reported with an overpotential near 57 mV and a Tafel slope around 43 mV dec⁻¹ in 0.5 M H₂SO₄.

Benchmark Conditions Must Be Explicit

η₁₀ and the Tafel slope are only comparable when the experimental conditions are comparable. At minimum, report electrolyte identity and concentration, temperature, electrode area, catalyst loading, substrate, scan or sampling protocol, reference electrode, counter electrode, and iR-correction method.

A catalyst tested on a polished metal substrate at one loading cannot be directly ranked against a catalyst tested on a porous foam or carbon support at a different loading without qualification.

Choose Electrolytes That Reveal Both Activity and Durability

Acidic Electrolytes

0.5 M H₂SO₄ is a representative acidic electrolyte used for evaluating HER kinetics. Acidic testing can provide a demanding assessment of catalyst stability because nickel- and cobalt-containing phases may undergo dissolution, surface transformation, or chemical restructuring under strongly acidic conditions.

Acidic measurements are particularly useful for determining whether a low initial overpotential is accompanied by sustained electrochemical activity. Post-test structural and compositional analysis is important when dissolution or reconstruction is possible.

Alkaline Electrolytes

1 M KOH is a standard alkaline electrolyte for HER evaluation. In alkaline media, the catalyst and electrolyte participate in a water-reduction environment, so the observed kinetics can differ substantially from those in acid.

Alkaline testing is important for nickel-based systems because nickel-containing catalysts are often studied in this environment. It also helps determine whether the catalyst maintains activity when water dissociation and hydroxide-related surface processes influence the overall reaction.

Test in Both Media When Practical

Testing in both 0.5 M H₂SO₄ and 1 M KOH helps distinguish intrinsic kinetic behavior from electrolyte-specific effects. Differences in η₁₀ or Tafel slope can reveal changes in reaction pathway, interfacial chemistry, conductivity, or catalyst stability.

A catalyst that performs well in only one electrolyte should not automatically be described as universally superior. The electrolyte must be treated as part of the catalyst evaluation, not merely as a background experimental detail.

Control the Electrochemical Measurement

Reference Electrode and Potential Conversion

Potentials should be reported against a clearly identified reference electrode and converted to a common scale when comparisons are made. For HER, overpotential should be calculated relative to the thermodynamic hydrogen-evolution potential appropriate to the electrolyte and measurement conditions.

The conversion method, calibration procedure, and whether potentials are reported on a reversible hydrogen electrode scale should be stated explicitly. Ambiguous potential reporting can make otherwise careful comparisons unreliable.

iR Compensation

Solution resistance causes part of the measured voltage to be lost between the working and reference electrodes. iR compensation is therefore important, particularly at elevated current densities.

State whether the reported polarization curve is iR-corrected, partially corrected, or uncorrected. Over-correction can produce artificially favorable polarization behavior, so the resistance-measurement and compensation procedure should also be documented.

Electrode Loading and Geometric Area

Catalyst loading affects the measured current, apparent activity, catalyst utilization, and mass-transport behavior. Powder catalysts should be processed consistently onto a conductive substrate or carbon support, with the loading reported in mass per geometric area.

The geometric current density used for η₁₀ is convenient but does not necessarily represent the true active surface area. Comparisons should therefore use consistent substrate area definitions and should distinguish geometric activity from surface-normalized or mass-normalized activity.

Electrode Preparation and Reproducibility

Reliable characterization depends heavily on powder processing and working-electrode preparation. Ink composition, binder content, dispersion quality, drying conditions, catalyst adhesion, and substrate cleanliness can all change the apparent result.

Replicate electrodes and repeated measurements are needed to determine whether a reported performance value is intrinsic or the result of coating variability. This is especially important for porous foams, nanosheets, and nanopowders, whose physical structure can change substantially during processing.

Add Measurements Beyond η₁₀ and Tafel Slope

Long-Term Chronopotentiometry or Chronoamperometry

A catalyst should be tested at a fixed current or fixed potential for an extended period to assess operational stability. Monitor changes in potential or current rather than relying only on a pre- and post-test polarization curve.

Stability testing should be paired with post-electrolysis characterization. A stable current does not necessarily mean that the original phase remains chemically unchanged.

Faradaic Efficiency

Faradaic efficiency for hydrogen verifies whether the measured electrical charge is being converted into the intended product. This is especially relevant for multicomponent nickel- and cobalt-based materials, where surface reconstruction or competing processes may affect product formation.

Activity and selectivity should be considered separately: a low overpotential is not sufficient evidence of efficient hydrogen production unless hydrogen generation is also confirmed.

Electrochemical Surface Area and Roughness

Porous and nanostructured catalysts can show high geometric activity partly because they expose more electrochemically accessible surface. Double-layer capacitance or another appropriate method can help estimate relative electrochemical surface area.

These measurements should be interpreted cautiously. Electrochemical surface area is method-dependent and is not identical to the number of catalytically active sites.

Electrochemical Impedance

Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy can help assess charge-transfer resistance, interfacial transport, and resistive contributions from the catalyst layer and substrate. It can be useful for explaining why two catalysts with similar η₁₀ exhibit different apparent kinetics.

Impedance results should support, not replace, polarization and durability measurements. Equivalent-circuit interpretation must be consistent with the actual electrode configuration.

Understanding the Trade-offs

η₁₀ and Tafel Slope Are Not Complete Rankings

A low η₁₀ may reflect high surface area, favorable catalyst loading, excellent electrical contact, or partial assistance from the substrate. A low Tafel slope may likewise be distorted by fitting range, resistance errors, or transport limitations.

Neither metric alone establishes intrinsic catalytic activity. Use them as standardized comparison points within a broader measurement set.

Acidic and Alkaline Results Are Not Directly Interchangeable

A value measured in 0.5 M H₂SO₄ should not be directly ranked against one measured in 1 M KOH as though the electrolytes were equivalent. Proton availability, water dissociation, ionic conductivity, surface speciation, and chemical stability all differ.

Cross-electrolyte testing is valuable for understanding behavior, but numerical comparisons should remain electrolyte-specific unless the comparison framework explicitly accounts for the differing conditions.

High Surface Area Can Mask Poor Utilization

Porous foams and nanosheet architectures can deliver strong geometric performance while containing regions that are poorly wetted, electrically disconnected, or inaccessible to electrolyte. Their apparent advantage may also depend on electrode thickness and gas-bubble removal.

Report morphology, loading, and substrate details alongside electrochemical data. Otherwise, it is difficult to separate material effects from electrode-architecture effects.

Nickel and Cobalt Stability Requires Verification

Non-precious does not mean chemically inert. Nickel- and cobalt-based phases can undergo oxidation, dissolution, phase conversion, or surface reconstruction depending on electrolyte and applied potential.

Analyze the electrolyte and electrode after testing where stability is important. Elemental leaching, phase changes, and changes in morphology can explain apparent activity gains or losses.

Making the Right Choice for Your Goal

Use the following framework to design a defensible evaluation:

  • If your primary focus is intrinsic HER kinetics: Compare η₁₀ and Tafel slopes under identical electrolyte, loading, reference-electrode, iR-correction, and fitting conditions.
  • If your primary focus is practical electrode performance: Include stability testing, Faradaic efficiency, catalyst loading, geometric area, and gas-management considerations.
  • If your primary focus is electrolyte compatibility: Test in both 0.5 M H₂SO₄ and 1 M KOH, and examine chemical or structural changes after electrolysis.
  • If your primary focus is reproducibility: Standardize powder processing, ink preparation, substrate treatment, catalyst loading, and replicate-electrode measurements.
  • If your primary focus is mechanistic interpretation: Combine Tafel analysis with impedance, surface-area assessment, controlled electrolyte comparisons, and post-test characterization.

A credible nickel- or cobalt-based HER assessment combines standardized kinetic metrics with electrolyte-aware testing, rigorous electrode preparation, and direct evidence of durability and hydrogen production.

Summary Table:

Parameter Description Key Points
Overpotential at 10 mA/cm² (η₁₀) Required voltage beyond thermodynamic potential to reach 10 mA/cm² Lower is better; must specify iR correction and geometric area
Tafel Slope Relationship between overpotential and log current density Indicates kinetics; values <40 mV/dec are good; specify fitting range
Electrolyte Acidic (0.5 M H₂SO₄) vs. alkaline (1 M KOH) Test both; results are not interchangeable
Stability Chronopotentiometry or chronoamperometry over time Assess durability; post-test characterization needed
Faradaic Efficiency Percentage of charge used for hydrogen production Confirm product selectivity
Electrochemical Surface Area Estimate of active area via double-layer capacitance Helps distinguish intrinsic activity vs. roughness
Impedance Charge transfer resistance Explains kinetic differences; should support polarization data

Elevate your HER catalyst research with KINTEK's precision laboratory equipment. Our portfolio supports battery R&D and advanced materials research, including slurry mixing, coating, and pressing systems (manual, automatic, heated, isostatic). Optimize your electrochemical evaluations—contact us today to enhance your lab's capabilities!


Leave Your Message